Who Owns Your Product When Someone Else Makes It?
Who Owns Your Product? IP in Manufacturing Agreements
You have paid for development, approved the packaging and placed your first order. It is easy to assume your business owns everything behind the finished product.
But if you needed to change manufacturers tomorrow, could you?
The answer depends on more than owning the stock in your warehouse. You may also need production drawings, formulas, software, tooling and permission to use technology developed by someone else.
Your manufacturing agreement should explain how those pieces fit together.
When the customer and manufacturer expect different things
Consider Mia, a fictional business owner who develops a modular display stand for small retailers.
Her manufacturer improves the connecting brackets, arranges production drawings and charges for custom tooling. The product sells well.
Later, Mia wants to move production. She discovers the manufacturer considers the files and improved bracket design its own, and says the tooling charge did not transfer ownership of the equipment.
Neither party needed to act dishonestly. Mia thought she was paying for a product she could manufacture elsewhere. The supplier thought it was selling finished goods using its own resources.
A clear agreement could have addressed that difference before production began.
Does paying for development mean you own the IP?
Payment alone does not reliably establish ownership. In Australia, engaging an independent contractor does not necessarily transfer the IP it creates to your business. If ownership is intended to transfer, document which rights are included and when the transfer occurs. IP Australia
Your supplier also needs to secure relevant rights from designers, engineers and other subcontractors involved in the work.
Separately, owning a physical mould or tool does not automatically give you ownership of the IP associated with it.
Who owns existing technology and improvements?
A manufacturer may bring technology, processes or formulas it uses across many customers. It is reasonable for it to retain those assets.
Distinguish this existing “background IP” from material created for your project. Agree who owns new drawings, developments and improvements, and what permissions each party needs.
For example, you might own product-specific developments while receiving a licence to use existing technology incorporated into the product.
Check whether that licence lets you appoint another manufacturer, modify the product and continue using it after the supply agreement ends.
If you are buying a standard white-label product, ownership of its underlying design may never have been part of the arrangement. Your business plans should reflect the rights you actually receive.
What can your manufacturer do with your information and brand?
An NDA can help protect information shared during initial discussions. The manufacturing agreement should also define permitted use, access and disclosure. ipaustralia.gov.au
Consider whether files can be shared with subcontractors, uploaded to external platforms or used for other customers. Support the contract with practical access controls.
Your supplier’s permission to apply your trade mark should also have clear boundaries. Address approved production, quality requirements, marketing use, overruns, rejected goods and leftover branded packaging.
What happens to moulds and tooling?
Tooling can be central to your ability to keep trading.
Clarify what the tooling payment buys, where equipment is stored, who maintains it and whether it can be used for anyone else.
Then agree how it will be released, including timing, transport and charges. Check whether unpaid amounts or local law could affect recovery.
Also ask whether another factory could use the equipment. A tool designed for one machine may need adaptation before production can restart elsewhere.
What changes when manufacturing happens overseas?
Australian registered IP rights do not provide worldwide protection. Consider protection where products will be made and sold, including when manufacturing takes place overseas for export. business.gov.au
Check the supplier’s legal identity and obtain advice about enforceability where action may be needed. An Australian governing-law clause alone does not resolve how you would recover tooling from an overseas factory. IP Australia recommends considering local assistance to establish an enforceable manufacturing agreement. IP Australia
Your agreement should also allocate responsibility for appropriate third-party IP checks and claims. A readily available component is not proof that you can use it in every intended market.
Can you actually complete a handover?
A useful exit plan covers current, usable production files, specifications, relevant testing records and tooling. It should also deal with outstanding orders, work in progress, remaining materials and branded stock.
Read that plan alongside exclusivity, minimum purchases, termination charges and conflicting supplier terms. The whole agreement needs to support the transition.
Start with one product
Ask: “What would we need to make this somewhere else?”
List the rights, files, knowledge, equipment and approvals. Then check whether your business owns them, has permission to use them, or has an agreed way to obtain them.
For manufacturers, this exercise also helps protect existing technology and clarify what development and transition support should cost.
Listen to the accompanying Elise Explains IP episode for a practical walkthrough. For a starting point in reviewing your own arrangements, use the free IP Audit tool, or visit my website to book a strategy call.
Resources
Visit Elise’s website or book a strategy call
Further reading from IP Australia:
- Who owns intellectual property?
- Non-disclosure agreements
- Manufacturing agreements and preventing overseas infringement
- What to consider before applying for a design right
- Protecting IP in China
Disclaimer: This podcast is intended for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should obtain advice tailored to your circumstances before acting on any information discussed in this episode.